August 02, 2012

by Miranda Logan

Category: Dog Behavior

Dominance in domestic dogs - useful construct or bad habit? Bradshaw, Blackwell and Casey

The paper by Bradshaw, Blackwell and Casey called “Dominance in domestic dogs – useful construct or bad habit?” reviews how the term dominance has been misappropriated in the context of domestic dog aggression.  It is not a trait of a single animal nor is it a motivation for how they interact.  It also discusses recent literature on wolf packs and feral dog packs. 


In the popular press, it is easy to use terms such as dominance and pack.   We need to remember that the word pack is just a name, just as a group of whales is a pod or a group of birds is a flock.  Wolf pack theory evolved back in the 60s based on premise that dogs and wolves, being of the same species, act in the same way.  As well, Dr Mech’s book (The Wolf: Ecology and Behavior of an Endangered Species) was published at this time.  Unfortunately this data was based on observing an artificial wolf pack (a group of captive unrelated wolves).   This led to the popularization of the terms such as alpha and dominance


Although the science has evolved, it has proven difficult getting the public and many professionals such as dog trainers and veterinarians to accept the advances that have been made.  Another frustrating aspect is how popular media has promoted the outdated theories through TV and the internet. 


When wild wolf packs were studied, it was found that there was very little aggression as they were co-operative family groups containing parents and offspring.  There is one breeding pair and other family members to help raise the pups.  Dominance hierarchy would not work in this situation nor be genetically beneficial. 


As well, understanding of the domestic dog has also progressed.  Dogs have co-evolved with us for thousands of years.  It began as scavenging waste from the settlements.  Domestication followed and through the years humans identified and developed specific breeds for guarding, hunting and herding.  


This paper is an important one for anybody who is interested in dog behaviour, whether they are veterinarians, trainers or the general public.  The better we understand our dogs, the more respectfully and humanely we can interact with them.

http://www.pawsoflife.org/Library/Behavior/Bradshaw_2009.pdf

Comments

Very nice article!

- Valli Parthasarathy on March 20, 2012

Thanks for the commentary and link to this article, it was a great read.

- Ryan Battles on March 21, 2012

That was a great linked article. Thanks for sharing. Russell Hartstein CPDT Miami dog training

- Russell Hartstein on August 13, 2012

Thank you for the article, everyone should read it…..smile

- Crystal Klatt on August 14, 2012

Add Your Comment

Commenting is not available in this channel entry.